From CJR: Journalism students can be “truly baffled” when confronted for plagiarism

Share

By Kristal Brent Zook on CJR, July 16

Perhaps Liane Membis, the Wall Street Journal intern fired recently for inventing quotes, started out with noble intentions. As Miss Black America-Connecticut last year, she spoke against high illiteracy rates among African American children and of wanting to represent black women “in a positive light.” We’d assume that Membis, a Yale graduate, brought these ideals to her internship at one of the nation’s most prominent dailie

So what happened? How did her high ideals come crashing down so horribly? As odd as it may seem, she may not have thought she was doing anything so terribly wrong. As the director of the MA Journalism Program at Hofstra University on Long Island (and a former adjunct at Columbia’s Graduate School of Journalism), Membis’s transgressions probably should surprise me, but they don’t. Many students these days are amazed—I mean, truly baffled—when confronted with their own unethical behavior.

Read the full post on CJR

 

 

A Plea for Aggregation Standards

Share

By Cyndi Stivers on CJR, May 8 – 

“There’s nothing new under the sun.” Thus spake my high-school teacher, then nearing retirement, and if I remembered nothing else (besides his rampaging eyebrows and alarming amounts of nostril hair), I would not forget this. His point, at the time somewhat dispiriting, was that ideas are continually repackaged and re-presented.

Read the full article on CJR

From CJR: Stieg Larsson’s posthumous gift to an embattled industry

Share

By Eric Alterman on CJR, Jan/Feb 2012 –

“Ironically — and apparently somehow below the radar of most journalists in America — the profession was recently blessed with what could have been, and still might be, the most effective propaganda vehicle for the societal significance of journalism I could imagine. His name is Mikael Blomkvist, and the paunchy, forty-year-old, lady-killing, black-coffee-and-bourbon swizzling, cigarette-smoking, crusading, feminist, Swedish journalist just happens to be the hero of perhaps the best-selling book series in the world.”

Read the full article on the Columbia Journalism Review website.

CJR: Long-form articles have plummeted at WSJ since late 2007

Share

From Ryan Chittum at CJR, Oct. 11, 2011

Story length in journalism by itself doesn’t mean much. We read too many news stories that are just too damned long.

But, on the other hand, without going long, it’s hard to achieve greatness. It sure makes harder to tell a story or lay out evidence, much less capture nuance and complexity. A longer story signals to readers that this story is important and that more work went into it.

This is to say that your average 4,000 word piece is just going to be reported more deeply and edited more heavily than your average 400-word FT news story, say. It’s possible there’s a great business journalism haiku poet out there, I suppose. Let us know if you spot one.

The Wall Street Journal’s page one has long been the standard-bearer for business writing and reporting, at least for newspapers. It took news and turned it into narrative nonfiction, everyday, twice a day, for decades. But Rupert Murdoch made it no secret that he disdained the Journal’s page-one tradition of long-form journalism, and it’s been de-emphasized under his ownership. That’s our qualitative impression, anyway, based on reading the paper, following the tealeaves, and talking to former colleagues.

Number of A1 stories longer than 1,500 words in the last decade. From CJR

Read the full article on CJR

 

Columbia Journalism Review articles about the FCC report on media

Share

The Columbia Journalism Review has published articles on the latest FCC report on the state of media and journalism. We’ve linked to both an article about the FCC report and a Q&A they had with the FCC report author, Steve Waldman.

Heavy On Problems, Light On Solutions: The FCC Report Has Landed CJR, June 9

- Q&A With FCC Report Head Writer Steve Waldman – CJR, June 20 & 21

 The Information Needs of Communities

You can read the full FCC report below.

 

 

CJR: Dealing with Numbers

Share

From Columbia Journalism Review: Serious Fun With Numbers

We’re drowning in data, but few reporters know how to use them. Read more.